Operational Losses At First Federal Draw Heightened Regulatory Scrutiny

by George Waldon  on Monday, Dec. 14, 2009 12:00 am  

The details are different, but today's financial vibe harkens back to the savings and loan crisis of the 1980s. It's a comparison that Larry Brandt, CEO of First Federal Bancshares of Arkansas Inc., himself has made as his S&L holding company endures losses of $25.6 million through the first nine months of this year.

These days, the culprit hammering the thrift's balance sheet isn't loan participations backing commercial real estate in unfamiliar regional markets. Direct loans to fund real estate projects closer to home are causing the current round of fiscal anguish.

"Our problems are in northwest Arkansas in Benton and Washington counties, with an oversupply of houses and lots," Brandt said. "We haven't made a development loan since 2006; we've had to rework some though.

"We saw the downturn in the economy coming, and when it hit, it hit quickly. That's when the bubble burst."

But it wasn't until this year that the red ink began splattering First Federal's financial statements. Battering the bottom line were allowances for loan losses that mushroomed from $6.4 million at year-end 2008 to more than $41 million as of Sept. 30.

Shares that traded at $9.50 a year ago have plummeted to $2.83, hovering near historic lows for the company.

The Office of Thrift Supervision formalized its operational concerns on Nov. 19 with a written directive restricting First Federal's activities and requiring OTS approval regarding certain actions.

Among the items requiring OTS approval are commercial real estate loans of $1 million or more, opening any new offices and accepting, renewing or rolling over any brokered deposits.

Many of the other restrictions were already in place when the company accepted $16.5 million from the Troubled Asset Relief Program Capital Purchase Program - the so-called "bank bailout" - in March.

"We thought it would be a good insurance policy to have that," Brandt said of the decision to participate in the CPP. "We truly didn't feel like we needed it. But it has provided more of a cushion to our capital.

"We're still making loans. The thing with loans is you have to have someone requesting loans. Credit-worthy borrowers aren't beating down our doors to get new loans."

The CPP money helped shore up the thrift's capital as First Federal waded into its troubled loan portfolio, dominated by real estate-related loans.

The six biggest categories for nonaccrual loans at the Harrison thrift as of Sept. 30 are land, $25.3 million; one- to four-family residential, $13.6 million; land development, $10.3 million; commercial real estate, $7.7 million; commercial loans, $3.4 million; and speculative one- to four-family construction, $2.7 million.

Total nonperforming assets and performing restructured loans of $101 million at Sept. 30 were written down to nearly $80.9 million, about 11 percent of total assets.

That write-down total compares with $55.7 million at year-end 2008, about 7 percent of First Federal's total assets.

Boosting loan loss reserves was the big-ticket item behind the company posting a whopping $23.2 million loss for the third quarter.

"We took a big hit, but we were aggressive in building up our loan loss provisions and doing what we needed to do to clean up the balance sheet," Brandt said.

He said paring its portfolio of real estate has become a focal point for First Federal management.

"That's a priority for us," Brandt said. "We're fortunate in that we don't have a $10 million or $12 million project we have to work through. We're not at a level we can't work out."

Real estate-backed loans totaled $517 million at the end of the third quarter, a decline of $24 million compared with nine months earlier.

Back in the Day

During the 1980s, venturing into new markets was encouraged by regulators who advised First Federal and other lenders to broaden their horizons if local loan demand wasn't good.

"Needless to say, everything went good for awhile and then the participation loans collapsed regionally," Brandt said. "We had our lumps then and worked through it. We had some losing years, but recovered and got through it by the early 1990s."

First Federal, one of only six remaining Arkansas thrifts, finds itself working with regulators and sorting through a tangled loan portfolio along with lenders around the nation.

"We're like most banks; we're trying to control our growth," Brandt said. "We're not going to be doing any new branching in northwest Arkansas. We've done all we're going to do in the near future.

"We're back to basics and conservative bank lending. Regulators are emphasizing this with lenders throughout the nation. Northwest Arkansas is still one of the best locations. It's one of the regions that will lead the economic rebound.

"I believe that, and a lot of people do too."

Real Estate Owned & Troubled Land Loans

The real estate owned portfolio at First Federal Bancshares of Arkansas is dominated by property in Benton and Washington counties and represents more than $27.9 million in bad loans as of Sept. 30.

Land and land developments recovered by the lender account for $11.8 million of that total, the biggest piece of the real estate owned portfolio.

With $25.3 million in nonaccrual loans secured by land, First Federal expects that tally to increase in the coming quarters. More than $20 million in loan loss allowances already are assigned to land and land development loans.


Nonaccrual Loans Secured by Land


52 single-family lots and 25 acres of undeveloped land, Fayetteville

Loan Balance: $4.59 million


80 acres for future residential development, Fayetteville

Loan Balance: $3.81 million


40 acres, proposed residential subdivision, Farmington

Loan Balance: $3.41 million 


35 acres, proposed residential subdivision, Fayetteville

Loan Balance: $3.4 million


60 acres, residential zoned, Fayetteville

Loan Balance: $3.3 million


29 acres for future commercial development, Springdale

Loan Balance: $3.2 million


96 single-family lots, Fayetteville

Loan Balance: $2.83 million


2.49 acres commercial land, Rogers

Loan Balance: $2.33 million


42 single-family lots, Cave Springs

Loan Balance: $2.18 million


24 acres, commercial zoned, Lowell

Loan Balance: $2.1 million  


Other, 20 loans under $1 million each


Total: $25.35 million


Real Estate Owned Land


110 single-family lots, Springdale

Loan Balance: $3.8 million


61 single-family lots, Lowell

Loan Balance: $1.68 million


63.3 acres for future residential development, Elm Springs

Loan Balance: $1.44 million   


48 single-family lots, Elm Springs

Loan Balance: $1.28 million


30.7 acres for future residential development, Lowell

Loan Balance: $1.25 million


35 single-family lots, Pea Ridge

Loan Balance: $654,000


10 single-family lots, Farmington  

Loan Balance: $593,000


Other, 29 properties

Loan Balance: $1.06 million

Total: $11.83 million



Please read our comments policy before commenting.