Pandemic Permitting: Virus Takes Minor Toll on Building Projects


Pandemic Permitting: Virus Takes Minor Toll on Building Projects

Building permit revenue makes up a small portion of a city’s revenue stream, but the number of building projects can signal a municipality’s economic state and growth potential.

So when the COVID-19 pandemic hit the United States in March, city officials in Arkansas worried, among many possible effects, how the virus might derail or hinder the building permit process.

It turns out that they worried unnecessarily. Instead the pandemic “made things kind of thrive,” said Dennis Sanders, the building safety director for the city of Fayetteville.

Sanders said the only permit numbers that were down in 2020 for his city were multifamily developments. He didn’t believe that drop had anything to do with the pandemic but was instead a result of the natural ebb and flow of such commercial projects.

Even so, Sanders said, the city has a number of apartment projects ready to go this year.

“No one came in and built new apartments toward the end of the year,” Sanders said. “We had some at the beginning. We have some that were in review, but nothing came out in 2020. I do have 13 buildings that are going to be [built] this year in 2021.”

Little Rock saw its permit revenue drop slightly to $2.43 million in 2020 compared with $2.62 million in 2019. That relatively small decrease was a relief after a couple of weeks of doldrums at the beginning of the pandemic.

“When the pandemic started and everything got shut down, we had about a month of slowdown for us, not quite a hiatus,” said Jamie Collins, Little Rock’s director of planning and development. “People were just taking stock. We did have that lapse a little bit. We were only down $187,000 approximately from the previous year, but our revenue is within what our revenue should be typically. We do have up years and down years.”

Collins said that without the effects of the pandemic, the fiscal year’s permit revenue would have surpassed 2019’s. “I think we were fine for the year,” Collins said.

Do-It-Yourself Projects

During the pandemic, many people worked from home and many also kept close to home rather than going out. That has inspired people to undertake do-it-yourself projects such as planting a garden or building a deck. On a city level, the homebound nature of the pandemic led to an increase in permits for additions and alterations to residential and commercial properties.

The city of Rogers saw permits for residential alterations or additions jump 45%, to 231 from 159 in 2019. William Hyde, the city’s deputy fire chief and building official, said the pandemic that closed Rogers Aquatic Center for the entire year led to an increase in residents wanting to install swimming pools.

The city issued 88 permits for swimming pools in 2020, up from 51 the year before. “If you call today to get a swimming pool, you might get it built in 2023,” Hyde said.

Hyde said Rogers met its budget goals for permits in 2020, collecting $1.15 million compared with $1.13 million in 2019. Hyde said a 16% increase in applications for business licenses also was a nice boon: The city collected $351,000 in 2020 compared with $303,000 the year before.

“I’m not an economist, but to me that indicates healthy business growth,” Hyde said. “There certainly was an increase in our permit collections. It indicates how healthy the area is.”

Jonesboro also saw an increase in renovation permits, but a tornado that struck the city in March played a large role in that. Derrel Smith, the city’s director of planning, said the city waived permit fees for tornado-related applications. Permits not related to the tornado almost doubled from 56 in 2019 to 100 in 2020.

“We had a lot of folks rebuild,” Smith said. “Since the pandemic we can’t see that it has slowed growth down from the permits that we have issued. That is a pretty big jump, but a lot of that was rebuilds from the tornado.

“Everything has continued to trend up.”

Fayetteville had 801 permits for additions, alterations and miscellaneous buildings for residential and commercial properties. That was up from 621 in 2019. “The additions and alterations I think had to do with people being stuck at home, trying to take [on] some of the honey-do list,” Sanders said.

“We didn’t experience a slowdown in that level of interest in development at all.”

WILLIAM HYDE
Deputy fire chief and building official, Rogers


Single-Family Shows Strength

Little Rock saw a slight decrease in the number of single-family residential permits with 391 in 2020, four fewer than in 2019.

But the year ended splendidly for the state’s capital with 51 permits in December, the best final month since the housing bubble burst in 2008.

“That shows us what is happening in the economy,” Collins said. “2020 was the third-best year overall since the housing collapse for single-family. I think this is a regular continuation of growth. Little Rock has always moved on. There has still been development.”

Fayetteville and Rogers both reported large increases in single-family permits. Fayetteville had 738 in 2020, up from 553, and Rogers had 402, up from 346.

These were “valuable homes at that,” Rogers’ Hyde said. “That tells the story. Commercial gives you a glimpse, but residential says more people are moving here.”

Sanders said Fayetteville’s permit revenue was just below budget, coming in at $1.4 million, approximately $100,000 less than projected. Sanders said the lull in multifamily permits was the reason, but he has projected revenue of $1.6 million in 2021, a sign of how optimistic he is about Fayetteville’s continued growth.

Part of his optimism is attributable to the number of apartment units on the horizon and the promise of some closed businesses reopening, perhaps after renovations by new ownership.

“I could get some revenue coming in if people are remodeling or opening new restaurants and new bars,” Sanders said.

Hyde said most developments start behind the scenes a year or two before they get to the permit and construction phase. Those meetings and planning sessions did not abate in Rogers in 2020, giving him the expectation that permitting will continue to be healthy in 2021.

“We didn’t experience a slowdown in that level of interest in development at all,” Hyde said.

Collins said that when the pandemic first began, the city, expecting a significant slowdown, reduced some of its field staff. That lasted only a couple weeks as business soon sprang back to normal.

“All in all, in the times that the world is in, I believe the city of Little Rock was strong,” Collins said.

“We had a lot of folks rebuild. Since the pandemic we can’t see that it has slowed growth down from the permits that we have issued. That is a pretty big jump, but a lot of that was rebuilds from the tornado.”

DERREL SMITH
City director of planning, Jonesboro


Building Permit Revenue
In millions

2020

2019

Little Rock

$2.43

$2.62

Fayetteville

$1.40

$1.60

Rogers

$1.15

$1.13

Sources: city records and city officials